The case
Mr Abdalla and Mr Hanna were joint owners of several townhouse units in Hinchinbrook, NSW. After their partnership broke down, they made arrangements to divide the units between them. One unit, Unit 16, was then transferred out of Mr Abdalla's name using a forged signature and registered in the name of a company connected to Mr Hanna's associates. No genuine payment was made for it.
What we showed the courts
- Mr Abdalla never signed or authorised the transfer.
- Mr Hanna forged Mr Abdalla's signature on the transfer. Justice Pike made that finding in the Supreme Court of NSW on 22 September 2025.
- The company that received the unit, Jarvis J Pty Ltd, gave no real consideration for it.
- The transaction was part of an attempt to defeat Mr Abdalla's rights and entitlements.
What the Federal Court decided
Justice Goodman of the Federal Court agreed and found that:
- the transfer was fraudulent and could not defeat Mr Abdalla's equitable ownership;
- a trust arose over the property (known as a Black v Freedman trust), requiring it to be restored; and
- recipient liability principles applied: a party cannot keep property obtained through a fraudulent scheme.
Why it matters
We are proud to have secured this outcome and to see Mr Abdalla's property rights upheld. If your property has been transferred without your consent, act quickly: get advice, keep every document about the property and the transfer, and do not sign anything further.
SKM Lawyers prepared this article as general information. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as such. Get advice about your own situation.
SKM LawyersBankstown