What the phrase does
Communications made in a genuine attempt to settle a dispute are generally protected: the other side cannot use them as evidence in court. In NSW this protection is found in section 131 of the Evidence Act 1995. The aim is to encourage people to settle their disputes without going to court.
It is the purpose that counts
The court looks at why the communication was made. It will be protected if it was a genuine attempt to negotiate a settlement, even if the words "without prejudice" do not appear. It is still sensible to use them, so the intention is clear.
The reverse is also true: putting "without prejudice" on a letter does not protect it if the letter is not really part of settlement negotiations. In Davies v Nyland (1975), Justice Wells noted the mistaken belief among some practitioners that anything said under the phrase is hidden from the court forever.
In Redman Constructions Pty Ltd v Tarnap Pty Ltd (2005), Justice Campbell held that there must be a real connection between the communication and a genuine attempt to settle. Protection can also apply to only part of a document, leaving the rest available as evidence.
Exceptions
The protection is not absolute. Without prejudice communications may be used as evidence, for example:
- to prove that a settlement was in fact reached, if one party later denies it;
- where the negotiations involved misleading or deceptive conduct, fraud or undue influence;
- to correct evidence that would otherwise mislead the court; and
- when the court decides who should pay legal costs, where an offer was made on that basis.
The takeaway
Use the phrase, but do not rely on it alone. Keep settlement communications focused on genuine settlement, and get advice before you put anything in writing that you would not want a court to see.
SKM Lawyers prepared this article as general information. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as such. Get advice about your own situation.
SKM LawyersBankstown